The Shrouded Woman/ La Amortajada
This is the first book in a while that I have sat down to start reading, and only got back up when I was done. The entire novella felt poetic, I adored the flow of the writing and it felt very easy to read in comparison to the two other books we have read so far. Along with that, I think reading something from a woman's point of view drew me in as someone who has been raised as one. While reading I went through a variety of emotions but often I just felt sad for Ana Maria, and all of the other women in the story. As Ana recalls memories from her life it becomes obvious the role women had in society at that time. Also, the constant comparisons between female characters. I could be mistaken but not once was a man's appearance described as in-depth as a woman's. Beauty, entirely defined by what men were attracted to, was constantly discussed. Contrary to the gender roles, which are less dramatically oppressive now, the male gaze is definitely as strong as ever so these parts of the story stuck out to me. I will not use this blog post to get into the details of the idea of the male gaze but I can safely say that all of the women in this book had it ingrained into their minds. Pages were spent describing Marie Griselda's beauty and how it affected those around her, both men and women. The women around her compared themselves and deemed themselves inferior causing anxieties of if they were good enough for their own husbands. Silvia is driven to suicide over time due to her husband's obvious interest in Marie. It is only Ana who sees past this and forgives the woman. This woman's effect on so many lives leads me to my next point, an irritating and depressing theme within this book was the lack of healthy or happy marriages which unfortunately was probably realistic. Ana Marie's retelling of her first love was filled with childlike joy until she had to have a herbal abortion (side note that was probably wildly dangerous at the time?) because he was not allowed to marry her. She then marries and by the time she feels the same way for her husband he has lost interest. So on and so on. The same can be seen with marriages like that of poor Silvia, and even Marie Griselda who while so beautiful still cannot seem to be happy.
I will be thinking about this book for ages and have so many other rambling thoughts that I really can't quite put into words, mostly revolving around Ana Maria's. and other characters, obvious mental health issues. My question for the class is: If you were to look back on your memories the way Ana Maria did after death what do you think you would be drawn to reliving? How would your views change without the pettiness and grudges we sometimes hold onto our whole lives?
... I really loved this book lol.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI love your post and I really enjoyed reading this novella too! I agree that it felt meaningful to read something written by a woman and a woman's perspective, I felt like this would be a story I would happily pick up in my free time.
ReplyDeleteThere could definitely be a lengthy discussion on mental health, gender roles and the male gaze. I felt these were very prominent themes throughout the book as well. The women were all succumbed to the male definition of ideal beauty in a woman, and that was saddening to me. If a woman saw another as "attractive" by a male's standards, she felt threatened and inferior. This constant comparison created division among the women and I found that sad but it also made me think of the ways in which that type of comparison still exists in today's world.
Hey, really liked your thoughts on the text, I chose your post because I myself had been asking the question you asked. I beleive I would choose to look at the good stuf, weather that persons memory was still in my life or not when I died I would like my last memeory lane to be of happy momemnts I pent with people I once loved. I dont think I would relive anything that would anger or saden myself.
ReplyDelete-Montserrat Avendano
Hi Dee,
ReplyDeleteThanks for the insightful post. I also really enjoyed reading this novel as it was filled with so many intimate moments in Ana's life and her recount of from being dead is beautiful, yet tragic. I think that if I were to look back on my life from the dead, I would fondly remember all my loved ones. Perhaps I would regret holding hatred for people who I have fallen out with since life is too short to hold on to pent up hatred.
Thank you for sharing such a great insight. I also felt sad for Ana Maria. Specifically, I kept on thinking about what the word "shrouded" could mean in this story. First, it obviously meant her current state as a dead person. However, I also felt that she was "shrouded" (as in covered up/ concealed) from any opportunities for her to be her true self. She, like all other women in the story, had so much potential; however, it seemed like the male dominance/ "mastery" took away any opportunities for women to fully achieve their potential. In this sense, I felt Ana Maria was shrouded both in life and in death.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely! Mental health, even that of corpses (how oxymoronic is that?!) seems to be a strong underlying theme here.
ReplyDeleteHello! Thank you for sharing your thoughts, I think you managed to greatly put an idea that I couldn't communicate into words. I definitely think that the male gaze plays a huge role in all of the women's lives despite being told from a woman's perspective - in a sense I guess this shows how ingrained the male gaze is in being a woman? It's such an important thing to remain aware of, even when reading a female author.
ReplyDeleteHi! I also really enjoyed the flow of this book. The constant theme of beauty and the way it was characterized stood out to me as well. The moments where I should have said something and the people that have left my life in unresolved manners were the memories evoked for me. It saddened me that Ana Maria only got her peace once she was dead and made me not want the same fate. Of course, this made me understand her more as there are such constraints when it comes to these situations. Thank you so much for sharing your insights.
ReplyDeleteHi Dee!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your post, as well I totally share your view of the novella. I also felt that it was hard tto stop reading as it seemed to flow so well. I also agree with the way that you touched on how you had empathy while reading. I felt too that the text was so eaily able to make it's readers share the emotion of the characters.
David Peckham
Delete